What is the SMAS, and why does every good facelift tighten it?
This comparison is based on how Dr. Prucz describes his own technique on the Phoenix Plastic Surgery facelift page — not on a generic overview of what other surgeons do.
A facelift addresses sagging facial skin, jowls, and deep wrinkles. To do that well, a surgeon has to deal with two different layers of tissue. The outer layer is the skin. Beneath it sits the SMAS (Superficial Musculoaponeurotic System), the layer that contains the muscles of facial expression.
Layer 1: The skin
The visible surface. Tightening only this layer is what some surgeons do — and it produces an unnatural, temporary result.
Layer 2: The SMAS
The deeper layer containing the muscles of facial expression. It must be tightened for a facelift to last.
That is the real dividing line in facelift surgery. The question is not only whether the SMAS gets tightened — Dr. Prucz always tightens it — but whether the SMAS and the skin are lifted together or separately. That single choice is the difference between a deep plane facelift and a SMAS facelift.
Deep plane vs. SMAS facelift: what is actually different?
Both approaches work on the SMAS. Where they differ is how the two layers move once they are lifted, and how the SMAS itself is tightened.
| Factor | Deep Plane Facelift | SMAS Plication / SMASectomy | How Dr. Prucz Decides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Layers lifted | The SMAS and the skin are elevated together as one unit. | The SMAS is tightened on its own and separated from the skin. | He always tightens the SMAS and separates it from the skin. |
| Direction of pull | The skin and the SMAS cannot be pulled in different directions — the main drawback of the technique. | The skin and the SMAS can each be pulled in the direction they need. | Pulling the layers in different directions is sometimes necessary, which is why separating them matters. |
| How the SMAS is tightened | Elevated together with the skin. | Plication: the SMAS is over‑sewn and tightened. SMASectomy: a section of the SMAS is removed, then repaired. | He performs plication but prefers a SMASectomy — more technically challenging, and it typically produces the best results for most people. |
| Goal of the lift | Restore a youthful appearance by addressing sagging skin, jowls, and deep wrinkles. | A long‑lasting outcome without a swept‑back look. | |
| Often combined with | Eyelid surgery, a neck lift, and possibly a brow lift for the most rejuvenated look. | He often adds liposuction and FaceTite skin tightening to refine the neck. | |
Technique descriptions are taken from Dr. Prucz’s facelift page. The right plan for your face is set at an in‑person consultation.
Why does the direction of pull matter so much?
In a deep plane facelift, the skin and the SMAS are lifted as one unit. That means they move together. When the skin and the deeper layer need to move differently, a technique that keeps them joined cannot do it. As Dr. Prucz puts it on his facelift page, the main drawback of a deep plane facelift is that the skin and the SMAS cannot be pulled in different directions, which is sometimes necessary.
Separating the two layers gives him that control: the SMAS and the skin can each be pulled in their own direction. Combined with always tightening the SMAS, this is how he aims for a long‑lasting outcome without a swept‑back look.
Plication or SMASectomy: which SMAS technique does Dr. Prucz prefer?
Once the SMAS is separated from the skin, there are two ways to tighten it. In a plication, the SMAS is over‑sewn and tightened. A SMASectomy removes a section of the SMAS and then repairs it.
Dr. Prucz performs both, but he prefers a SMASectomy. It is the more technically challenging of the two, and it typically produces the best results for most people.
The one approach he will not use: skin-only tightening
Some surgeons tighten only the skin. According to Dr. Prucz, that results in an unnatural and temporary result — which is why every facelift he performs includes tightening the SMAS.